Remember the article I linked to do with Badfinger and how they got screwed over by crooked managers and uncaring labels and how two members commited suicide as a result? Well here's another music industry horror story. You can read the entire article here.
I don't know how many of you might remember Carolyne Mas? She was a singer, multi-instrumentalist and songwriter from NYC. Back in the late 70s she was signed by Mercury records and released a debut album entitled simply "Carolyne Mas". And that's when the fun started. According to the article
Carolyne's first single, "STILLSANE," makes BILLBOARD's Hot 100, but fatal mistakes in promotion made by Mercury Records alienate radio stations, and a live performance for WPLJ, booked by her manager, causes key station and competitor WNEW, who broke Carolyne's demo tape, to drop her from their playlist, creating a ripple that would erase her music suddenly and permanently from the charts at a crucial time. Her career would never recover from this.
Dispite limited success in Canada and Europe "Carolyne Mas" did very little sales in the US. In spite of this she recorded a second album titled "Hold On" to resonable critical acclaim. She tours extensively to support the album but Mercury is having administrative problems so the album goes nowhere.
The single released from "HOLD ON" is "HE'S SO COOL," but the record label is going through administration changes, moving from Chicago to New York, and after the promotion flubb done on the first album, little or no money is spent this time. As guitarist Landau put it. "That album never got out of the box."
Carolyne performs throughout the country non-stop, travelling in an RV, and breaks a record in the south for the ammount of colleges who request her appearance at a conference in Washington D.C., but Just like in Graham Parker's "Mercury Poisoning," her album is nowhere to be found in the stores in each city where she plays to sold out crowds.
Meanwhile she is getting popular in Germany where a 'live album is selling well. Unfortunately she gets no income from it.
A live KING BISCUIT FLOWER HOUR radio show recorded in July 1980 is purchased by Phonogram Records in Germany to be released as an album for the exclusive purpose of promoting an upcoming 2-hour live television concert, "Rock Palast," on January 20, 1981, and a concert with The Boomtown Rats two days later. Called "MAS HYSTERIA," the record cover is designed to look like a bootleg, and though it was originally meant strictly for promotional use, due to popular demand this 6-song "limited edition" is released and reprinted in Germany year after year. The 12:51 version of "SITTIN' IN THE DARK" becomes especially popular in clubs and on radio (and still gets much airplay there today). "MAS HYSTERIA" eventually sells over 250,000 copies, ironically making it Carolyne's biggest-selling record anywhere. Because it is sold at a "nice price," she is ineligible for the accolades that a Gold Record would normally bring. She will also never see a penny from this record, her biggest success.
Undeterred she releases a third album. But by now she's broke. Now this is what really kills me.
Mercury records offers tour support, if she will give them 100% of her publishing rights
100% rights? What kind of crap is that. She rightly refused their 'generous' offer but unfortunately she could no longer pay her band and had to leave the music scene for five years while trying to straighten out her credit and legal problems.
You can read the rest of this sordid condemnation of the 'music biz' in the main article. I really wish a few of these music execs would get turfed out on the street penniless to get a taste of what they do to some artists.
I think it was Thomas Dolby
I think it was Thomas Dolby who once said "what is a record label anyway but a bank stupid enough to lend money to musicians." These days, there's less and less a label can actually do for you. Back in the day, labels were the only way to get distribution. Luckily, the internet solved that. Back in the day, it took a lot of cash to bank roll a recording session. Now, scrounge a few grand and you can set up your own studio.
These stories are sobering, and well worth reading.
If I were young and doing the band thing, I would stay as far away as possible from the major labels. Not many people get rich with the DIY approach. But, if your goal is go get rich, playing music is a really bad way of achieving that goal. There's more musical talent in the world than there are fans to support it.
There's a good side, though. Back before the recording industry arrived, people used to amuse themselves and their friends and family by playing music (as in, on musical instruments). In fact, the modern music publishing industry rose up due to the demand for piano sheet music, so people who don't compose could have something new to play.
Now that YouTube and MySpace (and ReverbNation, and all the others) give people a way to share the music they cool up in their basements and on their back porches, maybe we'll see fewer big stars but many more people making music a part of their lives--not as a profession, but for the pure joy of the thing.
bassplaying.com
I guess the thing that makes
I guess the thing that makes me see red over the music industry is the hippocracy they show by going after Joe Public for the odd download or going after Tab sites all the while they are screwing over the very artists they proclaim they are helping. It just makes me mad.
While I agree that the internet and home studios are helping even the playing field I still don't know how that's going to help the artist tour in support of a potential hit. In many cases the artist has to finance the tour themselves if a label won't finance it. And it seems like the labels want a lot, or all, of the rights in order to finance a tour. Wouldn't you think that a guaranteed percentage of the ticket sales should be enough? But no they want the publishing rights too.
I'm so glad I'm a chemist not a pro musician.
I wonder if it will return
I wonder if it will return to the way it was before there was big-music distribution? Local hits, local tours, smaller money. I'm thinking about the way things were when juke boxes and AM radio were the main distribution channels. I'm not sure.
But, yeah. Everything you said is spot on. And it's insane to sign over any rights just for tour support. If you're a composer, publishing royalties are your bread and butter. Sign away rights to your songs and you have nothing, not in the long run anyway.
The people in the best spot are those who have already made it via the labels and now can put out their stuff on their own and still make money (Nine Inch Nails, Radiohead, etc.). The one thing that the big labels are good at creating is name recognition on a big scale. Now that I've heard of NIN, I can go online and find their stuff. I no longer need big labels to bring it to my attention.
Which leads to another possible way out: as people find new ways to discover new music (e.g. Pandora, Last.fm, etc.) maybe the need for the big label PR engine will go away as well. Of course, if I knew the answers to any of these things, I'd be out there making a lot of money right now. :)
Glad I'm a teacher and not a pro musician.
bassplaying.com
actually....
all kind of depends on how much money you want to make from music.....i know of many here in ky that make nice livings (not millionaires but don't have day jobs) from just making their own cd's and distributing them through there gigs and what have you....sure you don't get national tour support but if you only play gigs in a small region and get a decent following you could make a decent living off it. plus even if you can get your tunes only on local radio stations you still get your performing and writings payments form ASCAP and BM.
------------------------------------------
Greg
Http://www.myspace.com/kybassmaniac
*and it harm none,do what thou will*
------------------------------------------
Greg
http://www.youtube.com/user/BroknDreamsBand
Http://www.facebook.com/brokendreamsband
http://www.reverbnation.com/brokendreamsband
*and it harm none,do what thou will*
I'm a big star Wheat.... the
I'm a big star Wheat.... the only problem is no one knows it yet....LMAO!
Yeah, the new technolgy is great for musicians. You can get your music to the people without a label. I would rather sell 5,000 copies of a CD myself and keep the money oposed to selling 500,000 with a major labe and end up owing them money.
Dave
hear hear
Now only to be able to get $15 to $20 a pop for that 5000.
Well......Ya know......?????
Right on, Dave. Hey, you
Right on, Dave. Hey, you should get your stuff up on ReverbNation if you haven't already (if you have, friend me). They have a royalties thing and a way to sell downloads and etc. All free to you. :) And you don't have to sign over your first born or anything.
Wheat
bassplaying.com
Thanks Wheat! No we don't, I
Thanks Wheat! No we don't, I will have to check that out..... Dear Lord am I going to have to try to upload music? Can I just send them a disc. I have a look Thanks again Wheat.
Dave
You can create an account,
You can create an account, send me a disc, and I'll log in and upload it for you. :)
Wheat
bassplaying.com